The Emancipation of Mimi, Mariah Carey

Oh man, was Glitter bad. It was such a flop, such a disaster that Mariah Carey’s label had to pay her in order to kill their contract. Charmbracelet, her 2002 follow-up, was not much better. So 2005′s Mimi may not have had very high expectations, but it bowled over the naysayers like a diamond-studded billy club. Produced by a myriad of studio stars — including Kanye West, Jermaine Dupri and the Neptunes — the album debuted at No. 1. The hit single “We Belong Together” made Carey the third most successful singles artist of all time (behind Elvis and the Beatles) and the most successful female one ever. We think that qualifies as a comeback.
Californication, Red Hot Chili Peppers

Rick Rubin makes his second appearance on this list with the resuscitation of the West Coast’s original surf-punk party band, slightly long in the tooth a decade after its breakthrough Mother’s Milk. (The man’s really good at revitalizing careers — just look at the album he did with Neil Diamond, of all people.) On its previous album, One Hot Minute, the Chili Peppers had brought in Dave Navarro to replace a key member, guitarist John Frusciante. Big mistake. That album was a disappointment, full of un-Pepper-like metal. Frusciante returned to help the band put together this gem, slam-packed with singles: “Scar Tissue,” “Otherside,” “Around the World,” “Road Trippin’” and the title track. It’s a sexy, classic California record.

























