Though there are plenty of reasons to still love Clueless, we’d be remiss if we didn’t mention one of its greatest accomplishments: introducing us to Paul Rudd. That smile, that wit, that awkwardly sweet charm — from the moment Cher’s cute, college ex-stepbrother Josh, played by the then unknown Rudd, appeared on screen, we were hooked. And though it took Hollywood a bit longer to recognize Rudd’s appeal, he eventually wormed his way into wider audiences’ hearts.
Happy Sweet 16: Top 10 Reasons Why Clueless Is Still Awesome
As our favorite '90s teen movie turns sweet 16, TIME takes a look at its best moments
