TIME
Magazine
Photos
Videos
Lists
Apps
Life.com
Style
Subscribe

Follow TIME

Facebook
Twitter
Google +
Tumblr

NewsFeed
U.S.
Politics
World
Business
Money
Tech
Health
Science
Entertainment
Opinion

SEARCH TIME.COM

Full Archive
Covers
Videos

Home
Movies
- Box Office Report
- Reviews
Television
- Tuned In
- TV Recaps
Books
Music
Populist
- All-TIME 100
- Books
- Movies
- Music
- Television
- Video Games
Video Games
Photos
Sports

Judging American Idol: The Final 3

By James Poniewozik | @poniewozik | May 19, 2011 | +

It was final three night on American Idol, which meant that the show packed a whole nine songs into a mere two hours. In their penultimate performance, the trio were mentored by Beyonce. Who was irreplaceable? Who proved not to be ready for this jelly? Click the pix for my reviews:

Read Last Week’s Review of the American Idol Performances

: Scotty McCreery, Michael Becker/FOX

: Lauren Alaina, Michael Becker/FOX

: Haley Reinhart, Michael Becker/FOX

: Scotty McCreery, Michael Becker/FOX

: Lauren Alaina, Michael Becker/FOX

: Haley Reinhart, Michael Becker/FOX

: Scotty McCreery, Michael Becker/FOX

: Lauren Alaina, Michael Becker/FOX

: Haley Reinhart, Michael Becker/FOX

Related Topics: american idol review, shows, Television, Tuned In, Uncategorized

Facebook
Twitter
Tumblr
LinkedIn
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Digg
Mixx
Del.i.cious
Google

Latest on Entertainment

Looking Around June 1, 2012

Disney's Fantastic Voyage

The kids are the go-to demographic on the Fantasy, the newest vessel in Disney’s fleet of floating theme parks
From our Partners
14 Revelations From A New Tell-All Book On Christian BaleHuffington Post

The Olympics, Reality Shows, and Canadian Cop DramasSlate
Critics Consensus: Men in Black III Is Solid FunRotten Tomatoes
Arts June 1, 2012

Grafitti Artist Bambi Paints Jubilee Tribute to the Queen

TIME meets the female Banksy bringing royalty to London’s streets

Melancholia: Lars von Trier’s Tree of Death

Upfronts 2011: CBS Unveils New Shows, Erases Sheen and Couric

blog comments powered by Disqus

Populist

Mini Miscreants: Top 10 Li'l Screen Villains

As we prepare for the Game of Thrones finale, we recognize Joffrey and nine other baddies who showed us that terrible, horrible things can come in small packages

Movies

E.T. at 30: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Our Favorite Extraterrestrial

Movies

Rock and Role: Top 10 Memorable Movie Performances by Music Stars

Movies

Rethinking the Movie Masterpieces: Richard Corliss Expands TIME’s List of Cinematic Greats
Photos

Miscellany

Before They Were Famous: Celebrity Prom Photos

From Mitt Romney hamming it up to Halle Berry taking the crown, see stars on their prom nights

More Galleries

Remembrance

Robin Gibb, 1949-2012: Remembering the Bee Gees Co-Founder

Miscellany

The Night Marilyn Sang to JFK: Rare Photos

Cannes Film Festival

The Best Fashion Moments from the 2012 Cannes Film Festival
Full ListMost Popular
Entertainment

TIME.COM

Before They Were Famous: Celebrity Prom Photos
All-TIME 100 Novels
Grafitti Artist Bambi Paints Jubilee Tribute to the Queen
Disney's Fantastic Voyage
Snow White and the Huntsman: The Fairest Feminist of Them All
Top 10 Novels of the 2000s
All-TIME 100 Movies
TV Weekend: Game of Thrones Wraps Up Season 2. How’s It Doing?
Brilliant Classroom Characters: The Top 10 Wicked Smart Actors
The 30 All-TIME Best Music Videos

3-Year Old Kicked Off Airplane For Crying

Zombie Alert: Man Throws His Own Intestines At Police

The Survivor

Blessed Are the Sleek? Why God Wants You to Be Thin

Full Coverage: Elizabeth's Diamond Jubilee

Naked Man Chews Other Guy's Face, Shot Dead by Cops

Newton, Reconsidered

Inside Mexico's Drug Tunnels

Mubarak's Life Sentence: A Game of Smoke and Mirrors in Egypt?

Before They Were Famous: Celebrity Prom Photos
Movie Reviews

High School: Today's Teens Contract Reefer Madness

School kids run wild, under the influence of magic brownies, and so do Adrian Brody and Michael Chiklis in a couple of surpassingly weird performances

Snow White and the Huntsman: The Fairest Feminist of Them All

The Intouchables: France's Biggest Hit Dares You to Resist Its Charms

Men in Black 3: Somebody Get Tommy Lee Jones a Gold Watch Already
TV Recaps

The Bachlorette: Season 8, Episode 3

The Bachelorette Watch: Sixteen Bachelors, Three Departures, One Trip to Dollywood

Highlights include Dolly Parton singing for Emily Maynard and one omelet named Shelly

Game of Thrones: Season 2, Episode 9

Game of Thrones Watch: Smoke on the Water, Fire in the Sky

Mad Men: Season 5, Episode 11

Mad Men Watch: Dirty Business

Dancing with the Stars: Season 14, Episode 17

Dancing with the Stars Watch: The Last Dance
More on TIME.com

6 Dead in Seattle Cafe Shooting

A Fashionable Fit: High-Tech Athletic Wear That Enhances Performance

Before They Were Famous: Celebrity Prom Photos

Powered by WordPress.com VIP

Stay Connected with TIME.com

Subscribe to
RSS Feeds
Sign Up for
Newsletters
Get the TIME
Magazine iPad Edition
Read TIME Mobile
on your Phone
Become a
Fan of TIME
Get TIME
Twitter Updates

NewsFeed
U.S.
Politics
World
Business
Money
Health
Science
Entertainment
Photos
Videos
Specials
Magazine

© 2012 Time Inc. All rights reserved

Privacy Policy
Your California Privacy Rights
RSS
Newsletter
Mobile
TIME For Kids

Subscribe
Contact Us
Terms of Use
Media Kit
Reprints & Permissions
Help
Site Map
Ad Choices
Custom Content

Our partners

CNN
CNN MONEY