Tuned In

HIMYM Watch: I Just Want to Have a Smoke. Is That So Wrong?

Quick spoilers for How I Met Your Mother coming up after the jump:

Largely self-contained episode of HIMYM this week, and a fairly crisp, funny if not spectacular one. So I’ll skip the deep analysis. I won’t ask what happened, say, to the implication that Robin was going to get in a serious relationship with her co-host Don (namely, how they get from this episode’s uncomfortable tighty-whities moments to dating), or gripe that the return of Marshall’s nemesis Arthur kind of fizzled out. Because I already did. The hail of bullets, then:

* Yes, Lily’s Harvey Fierstein voice was Harvey Fierstein. And quite an accurate choice, since Lily hails from my Brooklyn neighborhood, and Fierstein does, in fact, sound like many of the local elderly ladies after a lifetime of chain smoking.

* Whatever comes, or doesn’t, of Robin and Don’s relationship, I was a little surprised they managed to get laughs out of the age-old premise of the blowhard local anchor, especially his spellbinding story of working a network job with real dressing rooms: “No changing in the KFC bathrooms across the street.”

* So teenagers of the future are not shocked by, say, Barney’s lying to get women into bed, but they’re scandalized by smoking. Good to know.

* Enjoyed the last flashforward to the last time each of the characters smoked—damn, Future Ted really knows his friends—but I half expected it to take a Six Feet Under finale turn and tell us Marshall took his last smoke… the day he died!

Related Topics: Uncategorized
  • Latest on Entertainment

    Steve Granitz / WireImage / Getty Images

    2012 Grammys Red Carpet: Six OMG Fashion Moments

    From Nicki Minaj’s Red Riding Hood getup to Katy Perry’s head-to-toe blue ensemble, TIME rounds up some of the best (and worst!) sartorial choices at the annual music awards show.

    Cancel the Oscars, Air the After-PartiesSlate

    Facundo Arrizabalaga / EPA

    The Artist Silences the Competition at the BAFTAs

    The Oscar frontrunner wins Best Picture, Director, Actor and Screenplay at the British movie awards.

  • amrios

    …I loved the episode, it had me laughing outloud, from Lily’s smoking voice, the McRib, cameraman in their underwear, the way Marshall looked to the side when Arthur first talks about his dog, Marshall’s time traveling to hit his younger self, Barney’s “I’m always pre-coital”; loved every minute of it…only thing I didn’t like was Robin’s co-anchor; seems kind of sleazy for her…

  • tyrantking

    I thought this episode was horrible. I don’t mean to sound like a prude or anything, but if you’re going to decide in season 5 to inform us that they’ve all been smokers all along, there had better be a spectacular payoff. Someone better get cancer or die. Anything less is simply irresponsible. There wasn’t and I think less of the show today as a result.

  • http://procrastinationchronicles.com procrastinator

    the one thing that i find i like about this show is the thing that annoys me the most, the way he’s telling these endless rambling stories to his kids (i’ve never quite checked but do they change clothes, this isn’t all in one sitting, right?)… but in this show i can buy the ‘we never knew they smoked’ because Ted never wanted to tell his kids that they smoked, i buy it, though i agree a bit with @tyrantking that i might have wanted a better payoff, but i wont hold it against them…

blog comments powered by Disqus