Tuned In

The Morning After: Turn This Mothership Out

ABC

Watching the abbreviated launch of V is a strange experience: the show will air only four episodes (one more is left) before vanishing to reappear in midseason, and when it returns, it will have a new showrunner, so it’s anyone’s guess how the series will be retooled. It’s less like a TV series than notes toward a TV series, with the makers throwing out possibilities and approaches that might or might not play out as the alien-invasion serial goes forward. Watching it is like being pitched a TV series: what if we tried this? And then what if this happened? (Spoilers ahead.)

I thought the third episode of V was at least more intriguing than the second, even if it did not escape what seem to be fundamental problems: all, in a nutshell, having to do with the fact that the aliens are more interesting than the humans, yet the series spends far more time Earthside. So it was a big plus to get Erica on the mothership in the V security center, where she got to spend time among the Visitors and learn that their uniform flair doubles as surveillance cameras. (Question: why do the Vs have bilingual English-alien signage in what is supposed to be a restricted area?) Though I’m not sure why the Vs thought it would be reassuring to humanity for them to all dress like airline personnel.

Likewise, the hints of fissures and internal politics among the Vs could prove to be very interesting, as we learn more about how their society works, what their plan is and why some oppose it. (On the other hand, the revelation that Hot Alien Girl is Anna’s daughter was presented as a bigger bombshell than it was. Hell, not knowing V biology, for all we know Anna is everyone’s mother.)

Of course, there still remain some head-scratchers, like the purpose of the V sleeper cells (which still seem more like a plot device, giving the FBI something to investigate, than any practical advantage for aliens who managed to show up in the open and win humanity over). And the related question—why don’t they just wave a few lasers at us and do whatever they want?—which at least last night’s episode had the good sense to ask. Not to mention the fact that no human in the cast is as captivating a character as Anna.

Still, with only one fall episode left, it’s unlikely we’re going to get much more development on the alien’s dynamics, who John May is, and so forth. And with the show evidently being reworked before it reappears, we’ll have to see how much the new version matches what we’ve already seen. In the meantime, one more episode is a small enough commitment that I’ll finish out the fall run.

But I still wish the characters on the show would show me a little more humanity that’s actually worth saving. Otherwise come midseason, I’m rooting for the evil aliens.

Related Topics: the morning after, V., Uncategorized
  • Latest on Entertainment

    HBO

    Girls Watch: A Spartan Existence

    Hannah comes home to East Lansing and visits the netherland between college and full-fledged, independent adulthood, in an outstanding episode co-written by Judd Apatow.

    Adele Crosses Huge MilestoneHuffington Post

    Melinda Sue Gordon / Cogan's Productions

    Killing Them Softly: Brad Pitt's the Hitman, But the Movie's Not a Hit

    He’s a mob enforcer, and a cool dude, in Andrew Dominik’s laggard crime drama

  • deckerfamily03

    I agree the bombshell with Lisa (i think that’s the blonde gir’s name) being Anna’s daughter…not much of a bombshell at all. The only thing interesting about it is that the FBI agent’s son is “dating” her. So? wouldn’t it be the same with any of the other aliens? Guess we’ll have to wait and see what they mean by “he’s the one”. THEN maybe it will have some sort of significance.
    However, I loved it when the V trying to help get the partner’s memory back proved to be part of the resistance. I cheered on that one. Stuff like that is the only thing that really keeps me in on this. Other than that…not sure if i’ll come back when it airs again after next week. Depends on how next week’s show goes.

  • ferociouswalrus

    I am not particularly impressed with “V” either, thus far anyway, but I think that this was definitely my favorite episode of the three… it had a lot of ideas flying around and as a series it’s started to look more and more interesting. I particularly liked the scene we watched Anna practicing what she would say to the widow, and we got to see how easily she can turn her outward emotions on and off. That said, I agree with James’ assertion that the series is in trouble if the aliens continue to be far more interesting than the humans.

    It bothered me that the Zac Efron look-alike’s date with the alien girl ends with them making out without either of them mentioning the fact that she’s, well, an alien. I mean, obviously we’ve seen that these aliens can have sex with people without those people ever being the wiser, but in this case he knows she’s an alien. I love SF, and I can suspend disbelief about technologies or plot points, but I still need to believe these are real people. And a real person would want to know how this would work prior to jumping in bed with an alien, just sayin’. But that’s far from the show’s biggest problem.

  • mfbattle

    I don’t think they have really thought much of the show through. Why has no one questioned why the Vs look exactly like us (and by extension the fact that the young hot V and dumb bland boy have not mentioned interspecies sex problems)? Surely the Vs would use this to link up with religion (in God’s image for example). Why didn’t the FBI complain that a human was being taken into custody by the Vs? Glenn Beck goes mad that KSM might be sent to The Hague (based on nothing), but lets hand over the ‘assassin’ to an alien species. I like SF, but the story have to be consistent, even if aliens are shooting laser beams. And the whole terrorism FBI thing seems to be because of 9/11 rather than helping the story.

  • http://tvtattle.com/2009/11/18/odds-ends-107/ ODDS & ENDS — TV Tattle

    [...] will the new "V" impact the current "V"? // Morena Baccarin: Everybody should have my [...]

  • nickelking

    “Why has no one questioned why the Vs look exactly like us”

    That question was raised in the first episode.

  • http://eldritcher.wordpress.com/ eldritcher

    John May? John Galt.

    Same guy.

  • http://eldritcher.wordpress.com/ eldritcher

    “I like SF, but the story have to be consistent, even if aliens are shooting laser beams.”

    This show doesn’t respect that rule, or their audience, in my opinion.

    In the first episode, a guy in a wheelchair wheels himself into a church and proclaims, “Wanna see sumpthin?” Then he steps out of his wheelchair to show he can now walk. So if he can walk, why did he wheel himself in? Why not just walk in?

    In the 2nd and 3rd episodes, we saw Alan Tudyk’s character with scars where he’d been hit in the head. But he’s a lizard wearing a human costume! Clearly, the V’s repaired his costume. But why’d they repair it to show scars in it? (I also don’t understand why an injured lizard, still in a hospital bed, is required to wear his human costume while he’s recovering.

    If the writers/producers can’t tell a logical story at this level of detail, what possible non sequiturs can we expect to be fed when the main plot line unfolds?

  • mrbilliam

    I wish the reporter would ask them some basic questions: “What are your real names?” “What do you call your species?” “What are some differences in your biology from ours?” “Couldn’t you have shown up in a way that didn’t crash all our planes?”

    And I actually got really excited when Tudyk’s character announced he was going to hunt down Erica: I wanted to see the confrontation. The resistance fighter killing him actually disappointed me.

blog comments powered by Disqus