You asked for it—or at least a couple of you did—in this morning’s Idol post, so here’s an open-comment thread for tonight’s audition round of American Idol. Work it out, dawg.
This is shaping up or lack of being one of the flat years for American Idol!
From what I listened to in the contestants on Weds. evening I felt few should have made it this far while many that were sent home should not have been! There are times I just don't understand how or why a much better talent pool could not have been found while the judges were doing the city tours searching for the next big star! If the talent does not start shinning even a little I am going to stop watching, what I've seen thus far can be seen/heard at most any karaoke going on anywhere! Looks like the judges need to start going to Karaoke events to find some real talent!
What drugs and dope are NM doing tonight? She just judged the Alaska candidate while slurring her words. Let's get some quality talent to judge. This negates the whole mission of American Idol... JDB
TREVOR BLAKNEY SHOULD HAVE WENT THRU TONIGHT! THE GROUP HE WAS CHOSEN TO BE IN DID HIM NO JUSTICE. HE HAS A GREAT VOICE. I AM DISAPPOINTED IN THE JUDGES FOR LETTING THE PREVIOUS GROUP THAT FORGOT ALL THE LYRICS GO THRU!! ALL 4 OF THEM! NO FAIR NO FAIR NO FAIR!!! COME ON KEITH!