Judge Priest

One of the hallmarks of Hollywood racism was that no matter how substantial (if demeaning) a black actor’s part might be, he or she was typically billed below the white actors, however minor their roles. The two exceptions were Bill “Bojangles” Robinson, the Broadway star who famously danced down plantation manor steps with the seven-year-old Shirley Temple, and Stepin Fetchit, Hollywood’s prototype of the slow, shiftless black man. Robinson, essentially a specialty act in his movies, was admired, even cherished, by audiences of all colors. But Fetchit (born Lincoln Perry) was an embarrassment to many blacks, both then and especially later in the dawning of the civil rights movement. The lazy befuddlement of his characters seemed to represent the most contemptuous caricature of the race.
I don’t deny that. And I’m not rationalizing the racial gaucheries of his movies by saying, well, that was a long time ago. But anyone looking at Fetchit’s performances today has to notice their subversive, anarchic, movie-altering force. His drawn-out drawl and living-dead pace instantly stopped any scene in its tracks, brought the pace to a halt and monopolized the screen. When Fetchit was on, you watched him, because his acting style was unique. The rest of the players were striving for movie naturalism, and he, with a turtle’s intensity, was doing Kabuki. That no director said, “Stepin’ a little faster this time?”, indicates that the style worked for contemporary movie executives and audiences. So does this fact: Stepin Fetchit was the first black actor to become a millionaire.
He was one of director John Ford’s regulars, appearing in five films spanning a quarter-century. We’re choosing Judge Priest, where he plays Will Rogers’ handyman and, more or less, lawn jockey. In one scene, Rogers, whose pacing was nearly as leisurely as Fetchit’s, sends him on an errand, asking, “Gonna put your shoes on?” “Savin’ ‘em case my feet wear out,” is the eventual reply. Rogers: “As much settin’ around as you do, won’t be your feet that wear out.” Judge Priest, set in 1890, has bushels of this sort of humor, plus a quartet of mammies apostrophizing the Old Confederacy by joining Rogers in a chorus of “My Old Kentucky Home.” Yet the film is so relaxed, so amiable, that it might exist in some alternate universe where blacks weren’t chattel, and the races got along fine.
Imitation of Life

In this version of the Fannie Hurst novel that has been filmed at least four times, Delilah (Louise Beavers), a maid and single mom, dreams up a recipe for pancakes that makes a fortune for her employer Bea (Claudette Colbert) and herself. Bea has romantic entanglements, but the real conflict is between Delilah and her light-skinned daughter Peola (Fredi Washington). Peola finds that she can “pass” for white, and to become a part of the ruling society she renounces her mother. “Even if you pass me on the street,” she tells Delilah, “you’ll have to pass me by.” Bea is shocked by this seeming callousness, but Peola tells her, “You don’t know what it’s like to look white and be black.” After Delilah dies of a broken heart, Peola appears at the funeral and, in one of the cinema’s prime weepie tropes, throws herself on the casket. Is Peola guilty of matricide? Or does she represent a poignant solution to blacks hoping to escape the status of second-class citizens? To be accepted by whites, you just convince them you are white.
Washington, who came from Broadway, danced with Josephine Baker in Shuffle Along and acted with Paul Robeson in Black Boy, had a face, figure and natural elegance made for movies. She was cast as Duke Ellington’s tragic lover in the 1929 short Black and Tan. The director, Dudley Murphy, cast her in 1933 as a prostitute opposite Paul Robeson in the independently made The Emperor Jones. (According to Robeson’s son, she had a long-running affair with the actor-singer.) Washington’s dusky gorgeousness in Imitation of Life must have scared Hollywood bosses even as it tempted them. She got fourth billing in a 1937 Fox film, One Mile from Heaven, but that was it. She returned to New York, where she co-founded the Negro Actors Guild of America and was a casting consultant on the 50s’ two big black musicals, Carmen Jones and Porgy and Bess. She devoted most of her productive life to civil rights struggles that tried to redress the indignities that she and so many others had suffered.
More Best & Worst Lists
View AgainHollywood on Race
- About the List...
- Body and Soul
- Hallelujah!
- Judge Priest
- Imitation of Life
- God's Step Children
- The Duke Is Tops
- Gone With the Wind
- The Blood of Jesus
- The Jackie Robinson Story
- Native Son
- Carmen Jones
- The Defiant Ones
- In the Heat of the Night
- Sweet Sweetback's Baad Asssss Song
- Lady Sings the Blues
- Cooley High
- Killer of Sheep
- Richard Pryor Live in Concert
- A Soldier's Story
- Do the Right Thing
- Boyz N the Hood
- Eve's Bayou
- Bamboozled
- Madea's Family Reunion
- I Am Legend













