Every once in a while as a critic, you have an “Is it me or is it them?” review–one on which you part company with pretty much every peer in the world. Most of the ones I’ve had in the past (the American version of The Office [pro], Studio 60, Fat Actress annd Bette [con]), I’ve stood by. But maybe you’ll disagree with me about last night’s season premiere of Nip/Tuck, as did pretty much every TV critic in the country (with the possible exception of Alan Sepinwall). Maybe you disagree with me too, and this is your place to do it. Disagree away!
Also, I was remiss yesterday in not plugging last night’s airing of It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, though the various Charlie Brown specials are probably collectively as big a reason as any that I became a TV critic. We will all be judged on our sincerity.